Bury My Heart At Wounded Knee
Part Two
Heidi Wyman
Part Two
Heidi Wyman
The battle of Wounded Knee was the last mass extinction of Indians in America. This Battle eliminated the last major tribe of Indians, the Sioux. The Americans attacked the Sioux tribe, first taking all of their weapons so they could not fight back and then used their own weapons to kill all of the Sioux Indians. The tragedy at Wounded Knee was severe, but this was not the only time in history that we have seen a mass extinction of this extent. Hitler exterminated a great amount of Jewish people with the Holocaust, making it an event in history very similar to the extinction of the Indians.
The Holocaust and the Indian elimination have many things in common. The first similarity is the goal of the Americans and the Nazi's. Both groups wanted to wiping out/eliminating a race from the earth. The Americans wanted to eliminate the Indian race, so they could acquire their land and its riches. The American soldiers believed that "unless (the Indians were) removed by the government, they must necessarily be exterminated."(1) The Americans followed through with this plan coming very close to eliminating the Indian race. The Nazi's on the other hand wanted to eliminate the Jewish race because of strong hatred toward the Jewish from their leader. Hitler states in his speech before he was elected to power in Germany that if he was "ever really in power, the destruction of Jews will be (his) first and important job." He said "I will have gallows erected.... The Jews will be hanged one after another."(2) Again the Nazi's tried and killed much of the Jewish population in Germany. The Nazi's and the Americans had a very similar goal, elimination of a group of people.
When the Americans and Nazi's did not immediately kill their hostages, they would send them to live in horrible places. The American troops that captured hostages or tribes, would send and contain them in a small piece of land called a reservation. Most of the time these reservations were not fit for anyone or anything to live on. On one of the reservations the Indians were sent to live on, "there was not enough to eat in the empty land- no wild game, no clear water to drink, and the agent did not have enough rations to feed them all."(1) This was not all that troubled the Indians on the reservation. "To make matters worse, the summer heat was unbearable, and the air was filled with mosquitoes and flying dust."(1) There were many other reservations with conditions as bad as this one and worse. When the Nazi's did not sent the Jews to the gas chambers, they sent them to places like the reservations only they were called concentration camps. These concentration camps forced the Jewish people to do jobs for them without any payment. Jews who were sent to Auschwitz faced harsh working conditions, starvation and mistreatment. These people were also branded with a tattoo of a number, an ID number used to tell them apart. These tattoos were placed on the Jews in many different ways, one way was for the Nazi's to burn the number into the Jews chest and then dump ink into the open wound. This was only the start to the bad quality of the concentration camps, the Nazi's did not provide enough food or clothing, heart or other living essentials . The Indians and Jewish people were forced to live in horrible conditions, conditions no one should ever have to live in.
The Americans and Nazi's not only made life horrible for the Indians and Jews, they killed thousands of people. The Americans attacked the Indian race killing and mutilating including the women and children. This is best seen at the battle of Wounded Knee, the Americans went into the Indian camp and removed all of their weapons from them and then later they attacked this unarmed group killing almost all of the Indians, the men, the women and the children. The survivors were taken to a reservation where they were to live until death. The Jews were sometimes shot but usually were eliminated in a more efficient/consistent way. The Nazi's did not want to chance anyone living and they decided to build gas chambers where they would enclose the Jews and gas them to death. The Nazi's again showed no sympathy for the women and children, they saw the women as weak people who would not work with children and sent the women with children to the gas chambers first. The Nazi's then sent anyone they though were going to be to weak to work into the gas chambers next. The remaining people, mostly men, were sentenced to work for the Nazi's until death, which came within a year for most. The Americans savagely killed the Indians while the Nazi's savagely killed the Jews.
Although these two events had similarities they also had some differences. The Americans and the Nazi's both wanted to eliminate a race from the earth but they had different reasons. The Americans wanted to eliminate the Indians because they owned very valuable land, land that was excellent for growing crops, land that contained gold and silver and land the Americans could live one. The Americans attacked the Indians to strip them of their land, so the Americans could gain wealth. The Nazi's on the other hand had a very different reason for wanting to eliminate the Jews. The Nazi leader, Hitler, had a great hate for the Jews and was blaming them for the economical issues of Germany. He led his population to their problems stemmed from the Jews and that they should work to eliminate them. The Nazi's and the Americans had very different reasons for trying to eliminate the different races.
The Amount of people that survived the attacks of the Americans and Jews were different. The Indians were almost exterminated by the Americans. The Indian survival rate was very low, when the Americans were done attacking the Indians there were only a few hundred Indians left in each tribe, a number significantly lower then the amount the tribes started with. The Jews on the other hand had many more survivors. The Nazi's killed around six million Jews, some Jewish people surviving in Germany and around the world. The Jewish race had more survivors because their were Jews in other parts of the world and some of them ran away to other countries to survive. Unfortunately, the Indians, who were native to America ran out of places to run to. Today the Native American population is still much smaller.
The last difference between the events was that the Indians fought back while the Jewish people had very little means of fighting back. The Americans started their relationship with the Indians peacefully, this allowed the Indians to acquire guns and other weapons made by the Americans. These weapons allowed the Indians to fight back every step of the way while the Americans were attacking them and trying to steal their lands. The Jews on the other hand were striped of everything on them when they were taken to the concentration camps and they had no way of fighting back. Some of the Jewish population amazingly survived in the concentration camps, by hiding or running away however they were never able to attack/fight against their tormentors as the Native Americans did.
The removal/elimination of Native Americans and the extermination of the Jews by the Nazi's are similar historical events. In both events, a stronger more powerful group of people tried to eliminate another. Although there were some differences, the overall goal and outcome of the two events were very similar the attempted extermination of a race. These events had long term effects on the world.
The Holocaust and the Indian elimination have many things in common. The first similarity is the goal of the Americans and the Nazi's. Both groups wanted to wiping out/eliminating a race from the earth. The Americans wanted to eliminate the Indian race, so they could acquire their land and its riches. The American soldiers believed that "unless (the Indians were) removed by the government, they must necessarily be exterminated."(1) The Americans followed through with this plan coming very close to eliminating the Indian race. The Nazi's on the other hand wanted to eliminate the Jewish race because of strong hatred toward the Jewish from their leader. Hitler states in his speech before he was elected to power in Germany that if he was "ever really in power, the destruction of Jews will be (his) first and important job." He said "I will have gallows erected.... The Jews will be hanged one after another."(2) Again the Nazi's tried and killed much of the Jewish population in Germany. The Nazi's and the Americans had a very similar goal, elimination of a group of people.
When the Americans and Nazi's did not immediately kill their hostages, they would send them to live in horrible places. The American troops that captured hostages or tribes, would send and contain them in a small piece of land called a reservation. Most of the time these reservations were not fit for anyone or anything to live on. On one of the reservations the Indians were sent to live on, "there was not enough to eat in the empty land- no wild game, no clear water to drink, and the agent did not have enough rations to feed them all."(1) This was not all that troubled the Indians on the reservation. "To make matters worse, the summer heat was unbearable, and the air was filled with mosquitoes and flying dust."(1) There were many other reservations with conditions as bad as this one and worse. When the Nazi's did not sent the Jews to the gas chambers, they sent them to places like the reservations only they were called concentration camps. These concentration camps forced the Jewish people to do jobs for them without any payment. Jews who were sent to Auschwitz faced harsh working conditions, starvation and mistreatment. These people were also branded with a tattoo of a number, an ID number used to tell them apart. These tattoos were placed on the Jews in many different ways, one way was for the Nazi's to burn the number into the Jews chest and then dump ink into the open wound. This was only the start to the bad quality of the concentration camps, the Nazi's did not provide enough food or clothing, heart or other living essentials . The Indians and Jewish people were forced to live in horrible conditions, conditions no one should ever have to live in.
The Americans and Nazi's not only made life horrible for the Indians and Jews, they killed thousands of people. The Americans attacked the Indian race killing and mutilating including the women and children. This is best seen at the battle of Wounded Knee, the Americans went into the Indian camp and removed all of their weapons from them and then later they attacked this unarmed group killing almost all of the Indians, the men, the women and the children. The survivors were taken to a reservation where they were to live until death. The Jews were sometimes shot but usually were eliminated in a more efficient/consistent way. The Nazi's did not want to chance anyone living and they decided to build gas chambers where they would enclose the Jews and gas them to death. The Nazi's again showed no sympathy for the women and children, they saw the women as weak people who would not work with children and sent the women with children to the gas chambers first. The Nazi's then sent anyone they though were going to be to weak to work into the gas chambers next. The remaining people, mostly men, were sentenced to work for the Nazi's until death, which came within a year for most. The Americans savagely killed the Indians while the Nazi's savagely killed the Jews.
Although these two events had similarities they also had some differences. The Americans and the Nazi's both wanted to eliminate a race from the earth but they had different reasons. The Americans wanted to eliminate the Indians because they owned very valuable land, land that was excellent for growing crops, land that contained gold and silver and land the Americans could live one. The Americans attacked the Indians to strip them of their land, so the Americans could gain wealth. The Nazi's on the other hand had a very different reason for wanting to eliminate the Jews. The Nazi leader, Hitler, had a great hate for the Jews and was blaming them for the economical issues of Germany. He led his population to their problems stemmed from the Jews and that they should work to eliminate them. The Nazi's and the Americans had very different reasons for trying to eliminate the different races.
The Amount of people that survived the attacks of the Americans and Jews were different. The Indians were almost exterminated by the Americans. The Indian survival rate was very low, when the Americans were done attacking the Indians there were only a few hundred Indians left in each tribe, a number significantly lower then the amount the tribes started with. The Jews on the other hand had many more survivors. The Nazi's killed around six million Jews, some Jewish people surviving in Germany and around the world. The Jewish race had more survivors because their were Jews in other parts of the world and some of them ran away to other countries to survive. Unfortunately, the Indians, who were native to America ran out of places to run to. Today the Native American population is still much smaller.
The last difference between the events was that the Indians fought back while the Jewish people had very little means of fighting back. The Americans started their relationship with the Indians peacefully, this allowed the Indians to acquire guns and other weapons made by the Americans. These weapons allowed the Indians to fight back every step of the way while the Americans were attacking them and trying to steal their lands. The Jews on the other hand were striped of everything on them when they were taken to the concentration camps and they had no way of fighting back. Some of the Jewish population amazingly survived in the concentration camps, by hiding or running away however they were never able to attack/fight against their tormentors as the Native Americans did.
The removal/elimination of Native Americans and the extermination of the Jews by the Nazi's are similar historical events. In both events, a stronger more powerful group of people tried to eliminate another. Although there were some differences, the overall goal and outcome of the two events were very similar the attempted extermination of a race. These events had long term effects on the world.
Citations
(1) Brown, Dee. Bury My Heart at Wounded Knee : An Indian History of the American West. New York, NY: Owl Books, 2003.
(2) Dr S D Stein. "Statements by Hitler and Senior Nazi's Concerning Jews and Judaism." Learning, Teaching and Researching on the Internet. Nov. 1998. 24 Aug. 2008 <http://www.ess.uwe.ac.uk/genocide/statements.htm>.